David Vaughan
B.A. (Hons.), M.A., J.D.
National Practice Leader
Practice Areas
Employment Law
Location
Ottawa, Toronto
Experience
David Vaughan is an employment lawyer and National Practice Leader of Samfiru Tumarkin LLP’s Labour and Employment Law practice group. Working through the firm’s Toronto and Ottawa offices, he represents clients across Ontario.
David works with employers and employees with respect to all aspects of employment and labour law, including:
- Severance packages
- Terminations (without cause and for cause)
- Employment contracts
- Human rights issues
- Workplace harassment and discrimination
- Constructive dismissal
- Restrictive covenants
Respected by his colleagues, David commands a reputation for providing thoughtful, timely, and strategic advice to clients. He has established a track record of successfully resolving wrongful dismissal and other legal claims.
David regularly represents the interests of his clients before Ontario courts and other administrative tribunals. He takes great pride in understanding the specific needs of his clients and representing them with both passion and vigour.
Prior to joining Samfiru Tumarkin LLP in 2012, he articled with one of the top labour and employment law firms in Toronto. In his spare time, David enjoys playing hockey, reading, cooking, and spending time with loved ones.
Radio Hosting
The Employment Law Show on Radio
On Monday nights at 7 p.m. on Global News Radio 640 Toronto and 980 CFPL in London, David hosts the Employment Law Show. The live call-in program gives employees and employers in Toronto and the GTA the opportunity to talk to an experienced employment lawyer about their employment rights and workplace issues.
Topics of interest include severance pay, workplace harassment and discrimination, wrongful dismissal, constructive dismissal, misclassification of employees and independent contractors in Ontario, employment contracts and more.
Interviews & Media
2019
- Legal to secretly record phone calls the way Jody Wilson-Raybould did? – 640 Toronto
- Hamilton Woman Says Employer Forced Her to be Around Allegedly Abusive Chiropractor – 900 CHML
2017
- Concerns About Severance Offers for Fired Postmedia & Torstar Employees – 610 CKTB
- Susur Lee restaurant staff lose tips to IOU Policy – CBC News
- Sears Canada: Do Employees Have Any Rights? – Global News
- Sears Canada & Creditor Protection: Why This Is Bad For Employees – 640 Toronto
- TTC Employees to Undergo Random Drug Testing – 640 Toronto
Publications
Notable Cases
Reported Decisions
Pham v. Qualified Metal Fabricators Ltd.
David and Partner Jon Pinkus secured a groundbreaking and precedent-setting win in Pham v. Qualified Metal Fabricators Ltd. The pair successfully argued that their client’s silence during a temporary layoff — even after multiple extensions — didn’t amount to consent.
Read more about the win here.
Mazanek v. Bill & Son Towing
Mr. Mazanek was a 44-year-old tow truck driver who was misclassified as a contractor by his employer. He was terminated for cause due to serious allegations of theft. At trial, the court found that the employer had not been able to prove any of its theft allegations and that the employer’s main witness was not credible. Mr. Mazanek was found to be an employee. He was awarded 6 months of severance and the vacation he was owed for the two years prior to his termination.
Read more about the results here.
Czerniawski v. Corma Inc.
David’s client was let go for cause after 19 years of employment in the manufacturing industry, following an incident in the workplace. David successfully argued before Ontario Superior Court that employer failed to explore other disciplinary options and did not have the right to fire the employee without severance pay. Samfiru Tumarkin LLP won 19 months’ pay plus 10% for benefits for our client
Read more about his win here.
Alarashi v. Big Brothers Big Sisters of Toronto
David’s client was let go without cause after four years of employment, and only given four weeks’ severance pay due to the terms set out in the employment contract. David successfully argued that the termination clause in his client’s contract was invalid, and secured a substantial increase in common law termination pay.
Read more about his win at the Ontario Superior Court of Justice here.
Fillmore v. Hercules
David successfully defended their case at the Ontario Court of Appeal. The decision in Fillmore v. Hercules is important because it reaffirms that the duty to mitigate is not triggered unless the employer re-extends an offer to work out the notice period after the initial termination.
Read more about his win at the court of appeal here.
Carpenter v. Brains II, Canada Inc.
David’s client was let go without cause after eighteen years of employment, and only given eight weeks’ working notice and 18 weeks’ severance pay due to the terms set out in her employment contract. David successfully argued that the termination clause in her contract was not enforceable, and secured a substantial increase in common law termination pay.
Read more about the win here.
Education
David completed his law degree at the University of Western Ontario.
Prior to law school, he achieved both his Master of Arts degree in Political Science and Bachelor of Arts, Honours degree in Political Science at Wilfrid Laurier University.
More from David Vaughan
Discover more about your employment rights with additional resources from partner David Vaughan.Blog
Global News – Sears Canada: Do Employees Have Any Rights?
Sears Canada is seeking court protection from its creditors. Will the 2,900 employees eliminated in its restructuring plan receive ANY severance pay…
The Employment Law Show
Employment Law Show 640 Toronto – S7 E84
Fixed-term contracts, constructive dismissal facts, why you shouldn't accept Employment Standards Act severance pay, termination pay & your workplace rights…
Blog
TTC Employees to Undergo Random Drug Testing
David Vaughan, Partner at Samfiru Tumarkin LLP, explains whether or not the TTC is making a wise choice in regards to random…